| Ahly | MSA-cairo | Kavaasaa | About this site

 

addutitle

 

 

 

POLITICS

ISLAMIC THOUGHTS SOCIAL TECHNOLOGY ECONOMICS GALLERY BOOKS  
   AdduOnline  > Thoughts >  
 

Sunday December 07, 2003

 
 

 

Print Article

 

Send to a Friend

 

Download PDF

The burden of debt

Rasool Allah (Sallallahu alaihi wasallam) advised us to make dua, seeking protection of the trials of this world. One such dua is; “Oh Allah I seek refuge from anxiety and sorrow, weakness and laziness, miserliness and cowardliness the burden of debt and being over powered by men.”

The notion of debt causing anxiety and sorrow is something that is well established in the Islamic texts. Rasool Allah (Sallallahu alaihi wasallam) informed us of this issue. Although this is something that Muslims and non-Muslims are aware of, as it is a very real issue that affects all humans. In this day and age there are countless problems associated with the burden of debt. These problems were also prevalent among the people of the time of Rasool Allah (Sallallahu alaihi wasallam). Indeed the anxieties of debts have affected almost all peoples from all times. There are many references to debt in the ahadith of Rasool Allah (Sallallahu alaihi wasallam), verses of Quran and incidences involving the Sahaba (ra).

There is one such incident that highlights the importance of the correct etiquette and paying and demanding payments of debts. Abu Sa’id (ra) narrated that “An Arabian nomad came to Rasool Allah (Sallallahu alaihi wasallam) and demanded his loan which was due on Rasool Allah (Sallallahu alaihi wasallam). And threatened him with harsh treatment in case the loan was not paid off. Rasool Allah (Sallallahu alaihi wasallam) companions reproached him saying he did not know whom he was addressing in that manner. The nomad then said ‘I am just demanding my due’. Rasool Allah (Sallallahu alaihi wasallam) turned towards the Shahaba and said, ‘Why don’t you side with the person who is in the right?’ After that Rasool Allah (Sallallahu alaihi wasallam) sent a message to Khola bint Qais (ra) to ask if she could give him some dates as a loan till dates came to him. Khola (ra) said ‘alright, my father and mother be sacrificed on you.’ Thus Rasool Allah (Sallallahu alaihi wasallam) borrowed the dates and paid the loan of the nomad. Moreover, He (Sallallahu alaihi wasallam) gave a feast for his creditor. The nomad then said, ‘you have done me a favour. May Allah do favour on you.’ Rasool Allah (Sallallahu alaihi wasallam) said, ‘Those people are virtuous who pay off their loans cheerfully. In fact the Ummah cannot become sanctified whose weaker sections cannot get its right without distress and anxieties.’ ” This incident not only highlights the issue of debt within society but it also highlights the issue of how the creditor and the debtor should treat one another with mutual respect.

The stress and anxiety surrounding debts are issues that affect society in a detrimental way. Rasool Allah (Sallallahu alaihi wasallam) warned us of these problems. However if we are to look around us today we can see the reality of this phenomenon. In western societies there are many problems associated with excess borrowing. There are many anxieties and distresses associated with the poor and needy not getting their rights, and also anxieties and distresses are associated with debt itself. The UK and US have become credit card societies. There are many hidden, long term and short term, problems that are built into these types of societies.

Individuals within these societies suffer several psychological and social scourges. However these individual issues are projected onto the community as a whole. They are then actually exacerbated at this level. The sum, with regards to the detrimental affects of debt, is much greater than the parts.

The Consumer Debt Hangover

When the insatiable cycle of borrowing and spending subsides, and the debts that have been incurred have to be repaid, the debt hangover starts.

To give an insight into the fallout of the debt trap, consider the following statistics.

Evidence from the 'The British Association for Counselling and Psychotherapy' suggests that at least 10 per cent of students who sought counselling are suicidal or had attempted to kill themselves over debt problems.

Christmas = A Capitalist festival

As Christmas approaches so does the usual hectic frenzy of preparations for the winter holiday season. And as these preparations begin to gather momentum in every community across the western countries, one can't help but notice that what was once a Christian religious festival has now become a festival for a very different type of worship. High streets are packed with shoppers and churches are lying empty, retail stores are preaching consumerism to the masses, and the clergy continue to remain completely out of touch and out of favour with the population. However, the creed of enjoying one's self to the maximum and relentlessly engaging in a materialistic pursuit has lead to little tranquility for the worshippers at the capitalist altar.

In fact below the sparkling wrapping of Christmas being a time for getting merry, enjoying oneself and freeing oneself from the strains and stresses of life, the modern day demands and expectations of consumerist Christmas actually make it a very stressful and problematic experience for many. If you combine together a capitalist society driven by materialism, a financial market which hands out credit cards and personal loans like sweets, and advertising from every media and communication channel that mesmerises in its enticement, then what you have is an open trap, 'the debt trap' and few can escape its clutches if they choose to drink from this poisonous chalice.

It's not just advertising and easy credit that makes people spend

The aforementioned analysis does little to go beyond the surface and explore questions which are more fundamental in nature, such as why do people want to have the latest mobile phone or buy the latest car even though they cannot afford it? Why do people brave the clenches of the poverty cycle knowing full well the slippery slope it offers? To answer these questions, we need to have a brief look at the values and goals defined in the western society which takes its spirit from the secular capitalist viewpoint of life.

The oft quoted cliché 'eat, drink and be merry for tomorrow you die' is an apt place to start exploring the mindset fashioned by the western society. Self gratification is the goal, and consumerism is one of the clearest shapes that this goal takes. Part of consumerism is the overwhelming desire people have to express themselves through material means such as the desire to have the latest gadget or to wear the latest fashions that have hit the high streets.

Additionally, as a result of the capitalist identity, individualism flourishes and people want to express their individualism by being different in the way they dress, the way they look and the music and fashions they listen to and wear. This desire to appear in a certain way due to how the society judges people as successful or unsuccessful and this is what fuels the demand to obtain the latest high street releases.

So one cannot blame marketing on its own for developing the spending craze that has possessed so many consumers. The positioning and targeting of the marketing is almost always to tap into these distinct motivations that already drive society. For example, car adverts play more on the appeal he car has to the eyes of others (namely women) then it does on the functionality of the car itself. In fact all posters and images that can be seen in high street shops to entice consumers are actually enticing them by conveying the message that this item will enhance their identity.

Conclusion

The capitalist ideas of materialism and individualism are ideas that push people to seek happiness through the acquisition of material things. The images portrayed in the media are so overwhelming that many feel compelled to have the objects that they think will make them happy even if it means becoming indebted in the process. The misery is not felt until the euphoria wears off after the New Year where the reality of their debt burden begins to impose on their lives.

Spending is not disliked in Islam but the condition is that the financial means should exist for spending to occur. Spending is encouraged in the Islamic texts and miserliness is condemned. Many misconceptions have been created about Islam and spending which have falsely distanced many from the supremacy of Islam to man made solutions.

The debt trap is an open pit which many in western societies cannot escape from. Muslims should be wary of the pitfalls from western culture and capitalist financing that can lead to them becoming victims of this. Muslims should also be aware that the Islamic ideology is a complete way of life providing a moral and intellectual framework to build an Islamic society as well as a comprehensive economic, ruling and social system to govern the people's affairs.
 

GDP = Gross Deception

Depression is endemic in Western Societies

Two Misconceptions regarding Islamic Viewpoint on Spending

Factors contributing to debt trap