|
The cause of death is often misunderstood, and erroneously
attributed to various tangibles that surround a specific case. The
distinction between factors accompanying death, and what causes it,
is often lost to a casual observer. Death is a reality, and can be
defined as the end of life. Since death is a universal phenomenon,
its cause must be universally unique. However, it must be noted that
death may occur in many ways, being dependent on circumstances that
surround it. Therefore, the multiplicity of events in which death
occurs should not be indicative of death being a multi-causal
phenomenon.
The cause of death is defined as the factor that necessarily leads
to death, and death does not occur without it. It is also not an
effect of some other tangible factor. All other factors are cases in
which death occurs. Some of these factors may always coincide with
death, and some may not.
To illustrate this let us analyse two cases where death occurs:
(1) Death in a fatal state: Apparently stabbing seems to be the
cause of death, however stabbing cannot be the cause, since it is an
action initiated by an aggressor and therefore an effect of his
decision. Moreover, stabbing does not guarantee death in itself.
Therefore, stabbing only surrounds death and is not a cause of it.
Since death is universally unique, its cause must also be
characteristically unique. Hence if stabbing is the cause in this
instance, it must be the only cause wherever death occurs. This is a
ridiculous proposition. Similarly, physiological factors cannot be
causes of death, because they are effects of stabbing. The only
remaining possibility is that the aggressor inflicted the wounds
thereby causing death of the victim. In this regard, we must note
that the intention of the aggressor does not necessarily inflict
death upon the victim. None of the above mentioned factors guarantee
death, or exist independently. Conclusively none of these factors
are a cause of death. The determinant lies beyond our perception,
and the tangibles are merely descriptors of the event (i.e. death),
or cases in which death occurs.
(2) Death in a gas chamber: There should be no doubt in anyone's
mind that inhaling a poisonous gas (eg: Cyanide) always results in
death. Perhaps this would imply to some that toxic gases caused
death. Reviewing the scenario carefully, one notes that the presence
of gases in a chamber for example, is in itself an effect of some
other external factor (For example: opening the valves that allowed
fumes to fill the chamber). This proves that although inhaling toxic
fumes results in death, it is nevertheless triggered from outside.
Further more, upon identifying the triggering element (i.e. the
person who caused the fumes to fill the chamber), we notice that it
does not guarantee death of the victim. This is because the act of
opening the valves is not sufficient by itself to ensure death.
Again the cause of death is not any of the tangible factors pointed
above, nor a combination of them. These factors are merely events
surrounding death, and exist only as cause and effect of one upon
the other. However, the cause of death still remains obscure and
needs further investigation.
The cause of death should be universal, because death is the same
wherever it occurs. This implies that a particular incident of death
is not caused by the prevailing circumstances, but by a determining
element common to all such incidents. It should be emphasised that
although the tangibles involved may describe or even explain a death
scenario; the sequence of events leading to death will only
culminate in death independent of the perceptible factors mentioned
earlier.
However, our queries regarding the cause of death are answered by
Allah (Subhanahu wa ta'ala) on multiple occasions in the Qur'an.
Since Qur'an can rationally be proven to be the word of Allah (Subhanahu
wa ta'ala), we accept the answer as decisive and therefore part of
the Islamic Aqeedah. Allah (Subhanahu wa ta'ala) says,
"Nor can a soul die except by Allah's
leave, the term being fixed as by writing." (Ale-Imran:
145).
''He it is who created you from dust, then from a sperm, then from a
clot of blood, then He delivers you as an infant, then He makes you
grow up to attain full strength then makes you to grow further to
reach old age, though some one of you is recalled earlier. This is
done so that you may reach an appointed time and may understand the
reality. He it is who gives life and ordains death. Whatever He
decrees, He only commands it to be and it is.'' (Al-Mu'minoon: 67-68)
''No ageing person grows old nor is
anything reduced of his age except in accordance with a Book…''
(Fatir:11)
Therefore the cause of death is the expiration of time. It was
preordained, by Allah (Subhanahu wa ta'ala) how long one will live.
Medical science can only explain the failure of a living body when
death occurs However it would be erroneous to conclude that a mere
medical explanation is the cause of death. The cause of death is
beyond our perception, and this point has been established by
observing that none of the tangible factors fulfil the criterion of
being a cause of death.
Allah (Subhanahu wa ta'ala) says,
"Wherever ye are, death will find you out,
even if ye are in towers built up strong and high!" (AI-Nisa
: 78)
This Ayah was revealed as a response to those who said,
"Our natural term of life is short enough; why should we jeopardise
it (our lives) by righting (correcting) that in which there is no
personal gain?"
Here they are informed that death is inevitable and there is
nothing in their power to escape it. Therefore it is a folly to say
that if someone had not gone to Al-Jihad, he would have escaped
death or even lessened his chances of dying. Or that a tyrant ruler
should not be accounted brought to account, lest the speaker (the
one accounting him) is killed. Rather, the belief that death is
caused by an appointed time ordained by Allah (Subhanahu wa ta'ala)
gives a believer the tranquillity and courage in Jihad. It is a
source of courage for the one who speaks the truth and enjoins the
ma'roof and forbids the munkar. While the fear of death exists, to a
varying degree, in everyone, the Islamic Aqeedah stops it from being
a constant source of worry. We are all familiar with the vigour, the
Sahabah carried the dawah and fought with in numerous battles even
when the enemy out numbered and out weighed them. Indeed they
realised that the material strength of the enemy could not inflict
death upon them. Indeed they realised that the life can only be
taken by the Will of Allah (Subhanahu wa ta'ala).
|